✓ Source: REIN MLS #10635448 · record updated Sep 28, 2026 · synced every 2 min · your inquiry is never resold

$425,000Last list price

4beds

2.1baths

1,700sqft

$250per sqft

Off the market since Sep 28, 2026

8 Settlers Ln, Williamsburg, VA 23188

Off MarketResidential · built 1971 · JAMES SHIRE SETTLEMENT · MLS #10635448

Price per sqft$250compare with nearby sales Schools

WarhillHigh6.8

Lois S. HornsbyMiddle7

J. Blaine BlaytonElementary5.8

VaHome School Score Flood

Low / moderate riskZone X

flood insurance not required HOANoneno HOA fee on the MLS record Price while listed…checking price history Taxes$2,462/yrfrom the public record Condo feeNAnot a condo

Listing statusThis home is off the market

8 Settlers Ln was listed for sale on May 23, 2026. The last list price was $425,000. It came off the market on Sep 28, 2026. It is not listed for sale in the REIN MLS.

What is this home worth now?Similar homes for sale

OverviewAbout this home

Bonus: 2.875% VA assumable loan for qualified VA buyers. Tucked away on a quiet cul-de-sac Lane in Williamsburg, this beautifully updated home offers charm, character, and exceptional outdoor space with NO HOA! NEW roof, fresh interior and exterior paint, gorgeous hardwood floors throughout most of the home, and elevated trim details create a warm, polished feel from the moment you arrive. The 2026 kitchen renovation features granite countertops, soft-close cabinetry, pantry storage, & all appliances-including washer & dryer-convey. The family room offers custom built-in shelving & cabinetry, while the oversized 2-car garage provides abundant storage & versatile space. Additional highlights include a new shed (2026), hot water heater (2023), encapsulated crawl space, and floored walk-around attic with standing-height storage. Enjoy the oversized fenced backyard with a park-like setting, plus a welcoming front porch spacious enough for seating, entertaining, or relaxing with your morning coffee while enjoying the peaceful surroundings.

Listing courtesy of Kim Seay · RE/MAX Capital · REIN MLS #10635448

Facts & features

TypeResidential

Year built1971

Price / sqft$250

HOANone

Taxes$2,462/yr

CountyJames City County VA

MLS #10635448

Interior

Bedrooms: 4
Full baths: 2
Half baths: 1
Approx. sqft: 1,700
Stories: 2
Flooring: Ceramic, Wood
Ensuite bedrooms: 1
Total rooms: 8
Other rooms: Attic, Breakfast Area, Foyer, PBR with Bath, Pantry, Porch
Appliances: Dishwasher, Dryer, Dryer Hookup, Microwave, Elec Range, Refrigerator, Washer, Washer Hookup
Equipment: Cable Hookup, Ceiling Fan, Gar Door Opener

Construction & exterior

Style: Colonial, Traditional
Subtype: Detached
Foundation: Crawl
Roof: Composite
Exterior: Aluminum,Brick
Pool: No Pool
Fencing: Back Fenced,Privacy,Wood Fence

Utilities & systems

Heating: Forced Hot Air, Heat Pump
Cooling: Central Air
Water heater: Electric
Water: City/County
Sewer: City/County

Lot, parking & ownership

Subdivision: JAMES SHIRE SETTLEMENT
Ownership: Fee Simple
Garage: Yes
Parking: Garage Att 2 Car, Driveway Spc, Street
Possession: CLOSING
Disclosures: Disclosure Statement

Sources: REIN MLS record

Tom & Dariya's overview

Our read on this home

by Tom & Dariya Milan, REALTORS® · Brokered by LPT Realty

At a glance

Meet 8 Settlers Lane—a four-bedroom, two-bath home in Williamsburg with 1,700 square feet of living space. Built in 1971, this residential property sits on a convenient lot close to shopping, dining, and military installations. It's the kind of home that anchors homes for sale in 23188.

Keep searching in Williamsburg

See all Williamsburg homes for sale, including homes for sale in 23188, homes for sale zoned for Warhill High School, and homes for sale zoned for J. Blaine Blayton Elementary School. Nearby, look at Colonial Heritage homes for sale, Williamsburg waterfront homes for sale, Williamsburg condos and townhomes for sale, and new construction homes in Williamsburg.

Read the full overview ↓

Why this home stands out

This 1971-built home offers four bedrooms and practical floor plan, giving you room to spread out. Anyone comparing homes for sale in Williamsburg will appreciate the established character without major renovation demands. A solid foundation and sensible layout make this address worth a closer look.

JAMES SHIRE SETTLEMENT and the Williamsburg real estate market

Williamsburg blends colonial history with everyday convenience—tree-lined streets, local shops, and a relaxed pace that doesn't sacrifice access to modern amenities. You're in a residential area where neighbors know the value of a well-maintained home and a quiet block. The city itself sits at a crossroads: you're about 18 minutes from Camp Peary and 27 minutes from Naval Weapons Station Yorktown, making this location practical for commutes to either base. Shopping, dining, and services cluster nearby on familiar routes. Daily life here means short drives to what you need and a neighborhood that feels established and settled. Williamsburg homes for sale in this area tend to attract buyers who appreciate both the region's history and its modern conveniences.

What's nearby

Harris Teeter and Williamsburg Pottery sit less than a mile away for your grocery runs. Coffee is easy—Starbucks Coffee Company and 7-Eleven are both within walking distance. Dining options include ZENSHI Handcrafted Sushi, Heritage Grille, and Jersey Mike's Subs, all under a mile out. If fitness matters, Train with Bernie is just 0.6 miles away. You're never far from what you need on a daily basis.

For different buyers

Base commute and VA loan notes

Camp Peary is roughly 18 minutes away by car; Naval Weapons Station Yorktown adds another option at 27 minutes. VA loan financing is common and well-understood in this market. The home's four bedrooms and established layout mean you can move in without major surprises.

Room to grow

Four bedrooms provide separate spaces for different uses. Two full baths and a half bath handle morning routines without conflict. The 1,700-square-foot floor plan flows well, and the lot provides room to enjoy the outdoors.

Schools · VaHome School ScoreAssigned schools

Our own 1–10 rating, scored from Virginia Department of Education data.

HighWarhill High School

6.8/10

MiddleLois S. Hornsby Middle School

7/10

ElementaryJ. Blaine Blayton Elementary School

5.8/10

VaHome School Score — calculated by VaHome.com from Virginia Department of Education assessment, progress, and attendance data. Attendance zones come from the MLS listing record; confirm the current zone with the school division before making an offer.

How Far Is?

Driving distance by road and typical drive time via Google Maps, to the nearest location of each.

Also nearby

Distances are straight-line (as the crow flies) from this property, not driving miles. Places within ~1 mile, nearest first. Powered by Google Places.

Get new Williamsburg listings like this one by email

Williamsburg$360K – $490K4+ beds

By subscribing you agree to receive listing emails from Tom & Dariya Milan, Realtors, at most one a day. Unsubscribe anytime · Privacy PolicyBrokered by LPT Realty

Military Commute

Drive times to nearest bases

Camp Peary

DoD

22min·15.2mi

NWS Yorktown

Navy

23min·18mi

JBLE Ft Eustis

Army

27min·21.8mi

JBLE Langley

Air Force

47min·38.2mi

NSA HR

Navy

55min·50mi

Typical drive times from Google Maps, without live traffic. Rush hour and tunnel backups can add time.

Flood & environmentFlood risk (FEMA)

FEMA flood zone X · outside the high-risk area · FIRM 51095C

Flood Risk (FEMA)

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer · FIRM 51095C

Low / Moderate Risk

FEMA flood zone

X (low to moderate risk)

Base flood elevation

Not applicable in low-risk zones

Zone X is outside the Special Flood Hazard Area; FEMA doesn’t define a BFE here.

Property elevation

84.1 ft above sea level

USGS 3DEP digital elevation model

Outside the high-risk Special Flood Hazard Area. Federal flood insurance is NOT required, though optional preferred-rate NFIP coverage is still worth considering in coastal Hampton Roads.

Data sources: Flood zone and base flood elevation come from FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer. Property elevation is sampled from a single point on the parcel using the USGS National Map elevation service — actual elevations across a single property can vary by several feet higher or lower than the figure shown. Use these numbers as a starting reference and do your own due diligence (a professional survey or elevation certificate) before relying on them for any financial, insurance, or construction decision.

Hurricane Evacuation Zone

Not in a designated hurricane evacuation zone.

Source: Virginia Dept. of Emergency Management — Know Your Zone

Explore this neighborhoodColonial Heritage

Colonial Heritage is a gated, legally age-qualified 55+ active-adult community. It covers roughly 1,500 acres in the Lightfoot area of James City County.

$543KMedian sale · 12 mo

$200Sold $/sq ft

32dDays on market

23For sale now

$113KHH income

86.2%Owner-occupied

REIN MLS closed sales, trailing 12 mo · U.S. Census ACS 2024 5-year

Explore Colonial Heritage →

Neighborhood

Williamsburg homes for sale →

Value & historyComparables

Price context: similar nearby homes$315,000 – $525,000The 6 most similar homes nearby (same city, within ~20% of this size, ~2.5 mi; 6 sold). Context for the last list price, not an appraisal or an estimate of this home's value.

6516 Continental ST · 0.7 mi · 1,679 sqft$325,000 sold 2026-09

6524 Battlefield DR · 0.7 mi · 1,649 sqft$315,000 sold 2026-06

4605 Revolutionary WAY · 0.8 mi · 1,776 sqft$349,000 sold 2026-06

Own a home nearby? See what it is worth today: What's your Williamsburg home worth?

Sale & Tax History

List Price

$425,000

Price / Sq Ft

$250

Annual Taxes

$2,462

Monthly Tax

$205

HOA

None

Tax Rate (effective)

0.58%

Sale Timeline (this listing)

Event	Date	Price	Detail
Listed	May 23, 2026	$425,000	—
Price reduced	May 31, 2026	$425,000	−$25,000
Off market	—	$425,000	Last list price

Looking for multi-year tax assessments or prior sales? REIN MLS only ships data for the current listing. For full property history, check the city assessor record:

Williamsburg Real Estate Assessment

Tax data above from REIN public-records sync. Sale timeline tracked from this listing's first appearance in our feed forward; prior owner sales are not included.

Comparable Properties

Comps are selected by city, bed count, square footage and price proximity. Composite similarity score weights bed match, sqft variance, price variance, and straight-line distance.

CompareThis home next to what else is for sale nearby

Home	Price	Beds	Baths	Sqft	$ / sqft
8 Settlers Lnthis home, last list price	$425,000	4	2.1	1,700	$250
Loading nearby homes for sale…

Active comparables from the REIN MLS, the same homes shown under Comparable Properties. Context for judging the asking price, not an appraisal.

Questions about this home

Is 8 Settlers Ln in a good school zone?

The assigned zones on the listing record are J Blaine Blayton Elementary, Lois S Hornsby Middle School, Warhill (VaHome School Score 6.8/10). School attendance zones can change — always confirm enrollment with the local school division.

Is 8 Settlers Ln in a flood zone?

FEMA maps this parcel in Zone X, outside the high-risk Special Flood Hazard Area. See the flood section on this page for details and sources.

Is there a gym near 8 Settlers Ln?

Yes — Train with Bernie is about 0.8 miles away, per the cached nearby-places record for this address.

Where is the nearest grocery store to 8 Settlers Ln?

Harris Teeter is about 0.8 miles away. The closest dining on record is ZENSHI Handcrafted Sushi (0.8 mi).

Does 8 Settlers Ln have an HOA?

No — there are no HOA, condo, or association dues on the listing record for this property.

When was 8 Settlers Ln built?

It was built in 1971, per the listing record.

Answers generated from the listing record, verified school zones, FEMA data, and cached nearby-places data. Never invented.

Off the marketSee what this home is worth now

This home is not listed for sale in the REIN MLS. The home value tool estimates a current value from recent nearby sales.