Whittakers Mill Homes for Sale in Williamsburg, VA
Whittakers Mill sits on the east side of the Williamsburg, VA area. It is near where Route 199 meets Interstate 64. That gives easy access to Route 60 and the Busch Gardens area. The neighborhood blends single-family homes with attached townhomes. Some floor plans have main-level owner's suites. Lots range from town-square lots to larger wooded sites with ravine views. A clubhouse, swimming pool, fitness space, and walking and biking trails anchor the area. It sits a short drive from Colonial Williamsburg, William & Mary, and area shopping along Route 60.
6 homes for sale in Whittakers Mill right now.
6
Active Listings
$461,950
Median List Price
$197
Avg. $ / Sq. Ft.
46
Avg. Days on Market
18d ago
Newest Listing
Live from the REIN MLS, refreshed continuously. Stats reflect active for-sale inventory in Whittakers Mill.
Neighborhood10
Sold · last 12 mo
$437,000
Median sale price
$196
Median sold $/sq ft
35
Median days on market
$610,000
226 Galts Mill ARCH, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
Williamsburg, Virginia 23185
$550,000
406 Boltons Mill PW, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
Williamsburg, Virginia 23185
$484,000
409 Boltons Mill PW, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
Williamsburg, Virginia 23185
$439,900
202 Boltons Mill PW, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
Williamsburg, Virginia 23185
$380,000
319 Clements Mill TRCE #20B, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
Williamsburg, Virginia 23185
$349,999
109 Hite PARK, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
Williamsburg, Virginia 23185
Get new Whittakers Mill-area listings by email
Be first to know when homes hit the market in Williamsburg. Free alerts from Tom & Dariya Milan.
Free new-listing alerts from Tom & Dariya Milan. No spam — unsubscribe anytime.
What Whittakers Mill homes actually sell for
Computed from REIN MLS closed sales over the trailing 12 months — updates with every MLS sync, not a third-party monthly aggregate.
$437,000
Median sale price · 12 mo
10 closed sales
$196
Median sold $ / sq ft
closed sales with recorded sq ft
35 days
Median days on market
for homes that closed
$350K–$610K
Active listing range
6 on the market today
| Property type | Sold · 12 mo | Median sale price |
|---|---|---|
| Detached homes | 5 | $565,000 |
| Townhomes & condos | 5 | $429,000 |
Source: REIN MLS closed sales, trailing 12 months, computed by VaHome.
How Whittakers Mill compares
The 3 closest Williamsburg neighborhoods VaHome profiles, measured from map center to map center. Same 12-month REIN closed-sales math for every row.
| Neighborhood | Median sale | $ / sq ft | Days on mkt | Sold · 12 mo | For sale |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Whittakers Mill | $437,000 | $196 | 35 | 10 | 6 |
| Tranquility · 1.1 mi | $526,000 | $200 | 61 | 13 | 3 |
| Marquis Hills · 1.2 mi | $484,000 | $235 | 29 | 12 | 3 |
| Quarterpath at Williamsburg · 1.7 mi | $365,000 | $200 | 34 | 7 | 0 |
Source: REIN MLS closed sales, trailing 12 months, refreshed every 10 minutes. Neighborhoods with fewer than 5 closed sales are left out so no row rests on one or two homes.
What the homes in Whittakers Mill are like
Age, size, lot and price band of the 10 Whittakers Mill homes that closed since Oct 16, 2025, as recorded in the REIN MLS.
2019
Median year built
most homes sold were built 2017–2020
2,275 sq ft
Median living area
3-bedroom is the most common layout
6,534 sq ft (0.15 ac)
Median lot · detached
5 detached sales with a recorded lot
| Price range by type | Sold · 12 mo | Lower quarter | Median | Upper quarter |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Detached homes | 5 | $500,000 | $565,000 | $570,000 |
| Townhomes & condos | 5 | $395,000 | $429,000 | $430,000 |
Lower and upper quarter are the 25th and 75th percentile sale prices. Half of all sales fell between them.
HOA reality
100%
Sales with an HOA
10 of 10 closed sales where REIN recorded an association
$129/mo
Typical HOA fee
median of 10 sales that reported a fee
Fees are what the listing agent entered at the time of sale. Confirm the current amount and what it covers with the association before you write an offer.
Source: REIN MLS closed sales since Oct 16, 2025, computed by VaHome. Any figure with fewer than 5 recorded homes is left out.
Recently sold in Whittakers Mill
The latest 10 closings from the REIN MLS. Each opens the home's full sold record.
123 Mccormick PL, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
4 bd · 2.1 ba · 2,296 sqft
$430,000
Sold Oct 2026
410 Boltons Mill PW, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
4 bd · 2.1 ba · 2,569 sqft
$500,000
Sold Sep 2026
327 Clements Mill TRCE, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
3 bd · 2.1 ba · 1,720 sqft
$355,000
Sold Aug 2026
309 Boltons Mill PW, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
3 bd · 2 ba · 1,450 sqft
$388,000
Sold Jul 2026
612 Clements Mill TRCE, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
4 bd · 2.1 ba · 2,772 sqft
$565,000
Sold Jul 2026
512 Clements Mill TRCE, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
4 bd · 3.1 ba · 3,800 sqft
$660,000
Sold Jul 2026
124 McCormick PL, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
3 bd · 2.1 ba · 1,974 sqft
$395,000
Sold Jul 2026
111 Clements Mill TRCE, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
3 bd · 2.1 ba · 2,254 sqft
$444,000
Sold Jun 2026
600 Clements Mill TRCE, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
5 bd · 3 ba · 3,016 sqft
$570,000
Sold May 2026
202 Boltons Mill PW, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23185
3 bd · 2.1 ba · 2,230 sqft
$429,000
Sold Apr 2026
What buyers should know
Neutral counts from the 21 Whittakers Mill homes VaHome has mapped against federal and state hazard layers — shown the same way for every neighborhood.
0%
of mapped homes sit in FEMA high-risk flood zones
X · 21
0 of 22
mapped homes inside a Navy jet-noise (AICUZ) contour
Every VaHome listing shows its exact noise zone and Accident Potential Zone.
Zone NONE
hurricane evacuation zone
Va. Dept. of Emergency Management — Know Your Zone.
Sources: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer · U.S. Navy AICUZ via city GIS · Virginia Dept. of Emergency Management.
Census profile of the Whittakers Mill area
$131,939
Median household income
41.5
Median age
87.8%
Owner-occupied households
56.9%
Bachelor's degree or higher
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, American Community Survey 2024 5-Year Estimates (2020–2024), census-tract level for the Whittakers Mill area. Shown identically for every neighborhood.
Bases & commutes
Straight-line distances from the center of Whittakers Mill. Every listing page shows live drive times with traffic.
Listings & market data updated October 2026 · Live REIN MLS data
Whittakers Mill real estate FAQ
Where is Whittakers Mill located?+
Whittakers Mill is in the Williamsburg, VA area, on the east side of town. It sits near where Route 199 meets Interstate 64. The spot offers quick access to Route 60 and the Busch Gardens and Water Country corridor. Shops and dining around Colonial Williamsburg and William & Mary are close too.
What types of homes are in Whittakers Mill?+
It combines single-family homes and attached townhomes. Some floor plans have main-level owner's suites. Lots range from compact town-square lots to larger wooded sites with ravine views.
What amenities does Whittakers Mill offer?+
There is a clubhouse with multipurpose rooms and a fitness area. Outside, there is a swimming pool with a patio. A nature park has trails for walking and biking. Several park areas and a central town square serve as meeting spots.
About Williamsburg
Homes for sale in Williamsburg, VA sit in one of Virginia's most distinct and sought-after real estate markets. Historic Williamsburg sits in ZIP 23185. It blends buildings from the Colonial era with the buzz of a college town. The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation keeps them intact. William & Mary brings the campus life. Kingsmill on the James is also in 23185. It has golf-course living and luxury homes on the river. Ford's Colony, in 23188, is gated and master-planned, with private clubs. Powhatan Secondary and Stonehouse, also in 23188, have newer homes at lower prices. The local economy rests on William & Mary. It is one of the nation's oldest public universities. The Colonial Williamsburg Foundation and Sentara Williamsburg Regional Medical Center anchor it too. Second-home buyers come here from D.C., Northern Virginia, and out of state. That pushes the median home price above the Hampton Roads average. Most homes run $400K-$800K. High-end homes in Kingsmill and Ford's Colony top $1.5M. The Williamsburg-James City County Schools include Lafayette High and Jamestown High. Both rank among the best in the nation. Naval Weapons Station Yorktown and Joint Base Langley-Eustis are close by. Browse the latest Williamsburg homes for sale below. They refresh every 2 minutes from the REIN MLS.
Schools serving Williamsburg
Browse Williamsburg homes by WJCC attendance zone. Zoning is assigned by address and can change — always confirm a specific home’s zoned schools with the school division.
Looking for a realtor for Whittakers Mill?
Looking for a realtor for Whittakers Mill? Tom & Dariya Milan, Realtors know Whittakers Mill street by street. Brokered by LPT Realty. As Williamsburg real estate agents, they track every Whittakers Mill sale. 10 homes have sold here in the last 12 months, at a median of $437,000. Right now 6 homes are on the market. They also know what Whittakers Mill buyers and sellers should expect next.
Need a Whittakers Mill buyer’s agent to find the right home? Or a listing agent to sell your Whittakers Mill house? The first conversation is free. There is never any pressure, just straight local answers. Thinking of selling? Start with a free home value estimate for Whittakers Mill. It is instant, built from REIN closed sales. A hand-built report follows within 24 hours.
Explore more Williamsburg real estate
What residents say about Whittakers Mill
Honest, moderated reviews from people who’ve lived in Whittakers Mill. Share your own experience to help future neighbors decide.
No published reviews of Whittakers Mill yet. Be the first to share your experience.