Why this home stands out
What sets 5374 Gardner Court apart is its combination of compact, manageable square footage and a location that punches well above its size. Two full baths plus a half bath across 1,475 square feet means the layout works hard for you — no wasted space, no oversized rooms you'll never use. Add a 1988 build that gives the home real bones, and you've got a property that balances practicality with genuine livability in one of Virginia's most storied cities.
CHISEL RUN and the Williamsburg real estate market
Gardner Court sits in Williamsburg, Virginia — a city that carries centuries of history without feeling like a museum. The surrounding area has a relaxed, residential character: quiet cul-de-sac streets, mature trees, and neighbors who tend to stay put. James City County jurisdiction means you're in a well-managed, growing part of the greater Williamsburg metro, with solid infrastructure and a community that takes its parks and green space seriously. The broader Williamsburg real estate market draws a diverse mix of buyers — military families, retirees, remote workers, and history enthusiasts — which keeps the area stable and in demand across market cycles. Colonial Williamsburg, Busch Gardens, and the College of William & Mary are all within a short drive, giving the city a cultural depth that most comparably sized Virginia towns simply can't match. Daily life here moves at a comfortable pace, but you're never far from what you need.
What's nearby
Everything you need on a daily basis is within a half-mile of Gardner Court. Grab groceries at Zia's Sunrise or Food Lion — both just 0.6 miles away. For dinner, you're spoiled: Corey's Chicken Shack, Uncle Russ Dockside Seafood Market, and Captain George's Seafood Restaurant are all within half a mile, covering everything from casual bites to a proper seafood feast. Coffee is easy too, with a Starbucks and a 7-Eleven both at 0.6 miles. Fitness options are equally close — Smart Bodies Pilates, Rock Steady Boxing APEX PT, and the James City County Recreation Center are all under a mile away.
For different buyers
For military families relocating
Camp Peary is just 14 minutes from Gardner Court, and Naval Weapons Station Yorktown is roughly 22 minutes out — making this address a solid fit for service members stationed at either installation. The two-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath layout works well for a small family or a single service member who wants a dedicated home office. A VA loan can make the path to ownership here straightforward, and the low-maintenance footprint keeps day-to-day life manageable through deployments or PCS transitions.
For first-time buyers
At 1,475 square feet, 5374 Gardner Court is sized right for a first home — enough space to live comfortably without the upkeep of a sprawling property. Two bedrooms and two and a half baths give you room to grow, and the 1988 build means the home has established character without the uncertainty of something much older. The walkable access to groceries, restaurants, and fitness options means you can ease into homeownership without feeling tethered to your car for every errand.
More buyer questions
How far is 5374 Gardner Court from Camp Peary?
Camp Peary is approximately 14 minutes from 5374 Gardner Court under normal traffic conditions. The route is straightforward and avoids most of the congestion that affects other parts of the Williamsburg area.
How far is 5374 Gardner Court from Naval Weapons Station Yorktown?
Naval Weapons Station Yorktown is about 22 minutes from Gardner Court, making it a manageable daily commute for personnel stationed there. The drive runs through a mix of local roads and highway segments.
What is the property type and size at 5374 Gardner Court?
5374 Gardner Court is a residential property with 1,475 square feet of living space, two bedrooms, and two and a half bathrooms, built in 1988.
Is 5374 Gardner Court in a flood zone?
Flood zone information for 5374 Gardner Court is available through the FloodRisk tile on this page, which pulls current FEMA map data for the property's specific parcel.
Where are the nearest grocery stores to 5374 Gardner Court?
Both Zia's Sunrise and Food Lion are within 0.6 miles of the property, making grocery runs quick and convenient from this address.
Curious whether 5374 Gardner Court is the right fit? Tom and Dariya Milan at LPT Realty know this market well — reach out and let's talk through your next move.
