Why this home stands out
Built in 2018, 4800 Pilgrims Circle sits in the sweet spot between new-construction quality and an established setting. Five true bedrooms give growing households room to breathe — whether that's a dedicated home office, a guest suite, or a playroom that actually contains the chaos. Three full baths plus a half bath means morning routines don't require a scheduling app. At 3,638 square feet, there's genuine everyday comfort here, not just square footage on paper.
PELEGS POINT and the Williamsburg real estate market
Williamsburg carries a reputation that precedes it — colonial history, world-class living history museums, and a college-town energy that keeps the restaurant and arts scene surprisingly lively for a city its size. The 23185 zip code sits on the western edge of the Historic Triangle, putting you close to the James City County side of town where newer residential development has filled in around mature tree canopy and winding roads. Pilgrims Circle has that quiet, tucked-away feel without being remote — neighbors tend to know each other, and the streets are comfortable for an evening walk. Families comparing homes for sale in Williamsburg often note how the area threads the needle between suburban calm and genuine cultural richness. Colonial Williamsburg, Busch Gardens, and the College of William & Mary are all within a short drive, giving residents a backyard that most cities simply can't match.
What's nearby
Day-to-day errands are straightforward from Pilgrims Circle. The Williamsburg Premium Outlets and Monticello Avenue corridor put grocery stores, pharmacies, and big-box retail within a short drive. For coffee, the local Starbucks and several independent cafés along Richmond Road are easy stops. Merchants Square and the Colonial Williamsburg area offer a walkable stretch of restaurants, boutiques, and weekend farmers market energy. Waller Mill Park — one of the larger green spaces in the region — is close by for trail runs, kayaking, and family picnics. Among homes for sale in 23185, this address lands in a particularly accessible pocket of the city.
For different buyers
For military families relocating
Camp Peary is roughly 18 minutes away, and Joint Base Langley-Eustis (Fort Eustis) is about 21 minutes — both well within a comfortable commute for most duty assignments. A VA loan is a natural fit here, and five bedrooms handle PCS moves that arrive with extended family or a home-office requirement. Williamsburg's stable housing market and strong community infrastructure make it a reliable choice for military households on a tour of duty.
For families upgrading
If your current home has everyone tripping over each other, 4800 Pilgrims Circle offers a genuine reset. Five bedrooms and 3,638 square feet mean dedicated space for kids, guests, and the adults who need a quiet corner to actually finish something. Built in 2018, the systems and finishes are modern enough that you won't be immediately writing checks for updates. Families comparing homes for sale zoned for Lafayette High School and homes for sale zoned for Laurel Lane Elementary School will find this address worth a close look.
More buyer questions
How far is 4800 Pilgrims Circle from Camp Peary?
Camp Peary is approximately 18 minutes from 4800 Pilgrims Circle under typical traffic conditions, making it one of the more commuter-friendly options for personnel assigned there. The route is primarily highway, which keeps the drive consistent.
How far is 4800 Pilgrims Circle from Joint Base Langley-Eustis (Fort Eustis)?
Fort Eustis is about 21 minutes from Pilgrims Circle, a manageable daily commute for service members stationed there. The I-64 corridor connects the two points efficiently.
Is 4800 Pilgrims Circle in a flood zone?
Flood zone status for this address is detailed in the FloodRisk tile on this page, which pulls current FEMA map data. We recommend reviewing that section and discussing it with your agent before making any decisions.
What is the lot and property type at 4800 Pilgrims Circle?
4800 Pilgrims Circle is a single-family residential property built in 2018, offering 3,638 square feet across five bedrooms and three and a half baths. Specific lot size details are listed in the property data section of this page.
Does 4800 Pilgrims Circle have an HOA?
HOA status for this property is noted in the listing details section. If an HOA is in place, your agent can provide the current governing documents and any applicable rules before you move forward.
Tom and Dariya Milan at LPT Realty know Williamsburg homes for sale inside and out — reach out to schedule a walkthrough of 4800 Pilgrims Circle and get your questions answered by people who actually live and work in this market.
