4140 Windmill Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23188

Why this home stands out

Built in 2011, 4140 Windmill Road hits a sweet spot that older Williamsburg homes rarely offer: a floor plan sized for real life — three bedrooms, two full baths, and 1,756 square feet — without the maintenance overhead of a much older build. The construction era means updated mechanical systems, tighter insulation standards, and a layout that reflects how people actually use space today rather than how they did in 1975.

COLONIAL HERITAGE and the Williamsburg real estate market

Windmill Road sits in the western reaches of Williamsburg, Virginia, in the 23188 zip code — a part of the city that feels genuinely residential without being remote. The surrounding area is a mix of established single-family neighborhoods and open land, giving the streets a quieter character than you'd find closer to the Colonial Williamsburg corridor. Williamsburg itself is one of those rare cities that manages to feel both historic and livable at the same time. You're within reach of the James City County side of the metro, where locally owned restaurants, regional grocery anchors, and community parks fill out daily life. Families comparing homes for sale in Williamsburg often zero in on this zip code precisely because it offers that balance — close enough to everything, far enough from the tourist-heavy center to feel like a real neighborhood.

What's nearby

Heritage Grille is about a mile away — a solid neighborhood restaurant for weeknight dinners when you'd rather not cook. Beyond that, the broader Williamsburg corridor along Richmond Road and Monticello Avenue puts grocery stores, pharmacies, and coffee shops within a short drive. Route 60 and Interstate 64 are both accessible from this part of town, which means errands rarely require a long haul. For outdoor time, the Colonial Parkway and several James City County parks are easy to reach on a weekend morning.

For different buyers

More buyer questions