Skip to main content
VaHome.com
Williamsburg › ALL OTHERS AREA 113 › 444 Fenton Mill Rd✓ Source: REIN MLS #10633340 · record updated May 29, 2026 · synced every 2 min · your inquiry is never resold
444 Fenton Mill RD, WILLIAMSBURG VA 23188 - Main photo
$469,900
$256 / sqft · est. $2,875/mo →
3beds
2baths
1,837sqft
22days on market

444 Fenton Mill Rd, Williamsburg, VA 23188

Off MarketResidential · built 1972 · ALL OTHERS AREA 113

About this home

The listing, in the seller's words

Welcome to 444 Fenton Mill Road in Williamsburg—where comfort, space, and convenience come together. Set on a generous homesite, this inviting property offers a sense of privacy while being just minutes from shopping, dining, and major commuter routes. Inside you'll find a light-filled layout designed for both everyday living and easy entertaining. The main living areas flow seamlessly, creating a warm and welcoming atmosphere. The kitchen offers ample cabinetry and counter space and opens to the dining and living areas for effortless connection. The favorite room in the house is the large sunroom with 3 sides of windows overlooking the pool, decks, hot tub and huge backyard. There is also a perfect sized office space and a bonus room off the kitchen. The primary suite provides a comfortable retreat with a private bath, plus 2 additional bedrooms. Outdoor space invites you to relax, garden, or enjoy the peaceful surroundings. Don't miss the HUGE detached garage with a workbench.

Listing courtesy of Nan Piland · Liz Moore & Associates LLC · REIN MLS #10633340

Schools

Info provided by GreatSchools

Facts & features

The record, sourced

Type

Residential

Year built

1972

Price / sqft

$256

HOA

None

Taxes

$3,595/yr

County

York County VA

Waterfront

Yes

MLS #

10633340

Interior

Bedrooms
3
Full baths
2
Approx. sqft
1,837
Stories
1
Flooring
Carpet, Ceramic, Wood
Ensuite bedrooms
1
First-floor bed & full bath
Yes
Total rooms
9
Other rooms
1st Floor BR, 1st Floor Primary BR, Attic, Foyer, PBR with Bath, Office/Study, Sun Room, Utility Closet, Workshop
Appliances
Dishwasher, Dryer, Range, Elec Range, Refrigerator, Washer
Equipment
Cable Hookup, Ceiling Fan, Gar Door Opener, Hot Tub

Construction & exterior

Style
Ranch
Subtype
Detached
Foundation
Crawl
Roof
Composite
Exterior
Brick
Pool
In Ground Pool
Fencing
Partial
Waterfront
Not Waterfront

Utilities & systems

Heating
Forced Hot Air, Oil
Cooling
Central Air, Heat Pump
Water heater
Electric
Water
Well
Sewer
Septic

Lot, parking & ownership

Lot size
3.1100
Subdivision
ALL OTHERS AREA 113
Zoning
RR
Ownership
Fee Simple
Garage
Yes
Parking
Garage Att 3+ Car, Oversized Gar, Driveway Spc
Possession
CLOSING
Disclosures
Estate, Related to Seller

Sources: REIN MLS record · null fields are suppressed, never faked

Flood & environment

FEMA flood zone X · outside the high-risk area · FIRM 51199C

Flood Risk

Looking up FEMA flood zone…

Hurricane Evacuation Zone

Not in a designated hurricane evacuation zone.

Source: Virginia Dept. of Emergency Management — Know Your Zone

Explore this neighborhood

Wexford Hills

Wexford Hills is an established community in James City County in the Williamsburg, VA area, set on roughly 340 mostly wooded, rolling acres reached off Interstate 64 at exit 234.

$457K

Median sale · 12 mo

$195

Sold $/sq ft

13d

Days on market

3

For sale now

$119K

HH income

88.2%

Owner-occupied

REIN MLS closed sales, trailing 12 mo · U.S. Census ACS 2024 5-year

Explore Wexford Hills →
Map of Wexford Hills with neighborhood boundaryNeighborhood

Williamsburg homes for sale →

Location intelligence

Minutes to real places, not a score

Location & Neighborhood

Places within ~1 mile, ordered by distance from this property. Powered by Google Places.

Military Commute

Drive times to nearest bases

Drive times via Google Maps with current traffic patterns. Times are typical and may vary by time of day. Use the "Analyze" button up top to see live drive time to your saved base.

The numbers

Run the real carrying cost

Estimates only — taxes come from the public record; confirm rates with your lender. VA-eligible buyers: $0-down financing may apply.

Estimate your monthly payment

$2,875/mo

Principal & interest

$2,438

Property tax

$300

Home insurance

$137

PMI

None

HOA

None

Estimate only. Insurance assumed at 0.35% of home value annually. Actual taxes, insurance, and rate will vary by lender, credit, and property. Contact a lender for a personalized quote.

Value & history

Judge value on real ground

Why we show no algorithmic estimate.

National AVMs misprice homes whose value drivers they can't see. Instead: the sourced assessment above, the carrying cost, real price history, and honest comparables below.

Price context — similar nearby homes

$345,000 – $500,000

The 6 most similar homes nearby (same city, within ~20% of this size, ~2.5 mi; 6 sold). Context for judging the asking price — not an appraisal or an estimate of this home's value.

118 Indiana · 1.2 mi · 1,782 sqft$415,000 sold 2026-06
107 Chapel Hill LN · 1.4 mi · 1,679 sqft$390,000 sold 2026-03
4605 Revolutionary WAY · 2.1 mi · 1,776 sqft$349,000 sold 2026-06

Sale & Tax History

List Price

$469,900

Price / Sq Ft

$256

Annual Taxes

$3,595

Monthly Tax

$300

HOA

None

Tax Rate (effective)

0.77%

Sale Timeline (this listing)

EventDatePriceDetail
ListedMay 7, 2026$469,900—
Currently listed—$469,900—

Looking for multi-year tax assessments or prior sales? REIN MLS only ships data for the current listing. For full property history, check the city assessor record:

Williamsburg Real Estate Assessment

Tax data above from REIN public-records sync. Sale timeline tracked from this listing's first appearance in our feed forward; prior owner sales are not included.

Comparable Properties

Comps are selected by city, bed count, square footage and price proximity. Composite similarity score weights bed match, sqft variance, price variance, and straight-line distance.

Questions buyers ask

Real questions, answered from the record

Is 444 Fenton Mill Rd in a good school zone?+
The assigned zones on the listing record are Waller Mill Elementary (GreatSchools 8/10), Queens Lake Middle (GreatSchools 8/10), Bruton (GreatSchools 6/10). School attendance zones can change — always confirm enrollment with the local school division.
Is 444 Fenton Mill Rd in a flood zone?+
FEMA maps this parcel in Zone X, outside the high-risk Special Flood Hazard Area. See the flood section on this page for details and sources.
Does 444 Fenton Mill Rd have an HOA?+
No — there are no HOA, condo, or association dues on the listing record for this property.
When was 444 Fenton Mill Rd built?+
It was built in 1972, per the listing record.

Answers generated from the listing record, verified school zones, FEMA data, and cached nearby-places data — never invented.

The people

You'll talk to a person, not a lead queue

TD

Tom & Dariya Milan

LPT Realty · Hampton Roads · answer their own phone

✓ Your inquiry goes to Tom & Dariya — never sold to strangers

Listing courtesy of Nan Piland · Liz Moore & Associates LLC · REIN MLS #10633340

Call or text (757) 777-7577

Ask Dariya — instant answers

Schools, flood, drive times, what it really costs to own — answered from this page's data, by chat or voice.

Schedule a private tour

Free, no obligation — your inquiry goes to Tom & Dariya, never resold.

See it in person — the record only says so much.

Call or text (757) 777-7577

444 Fenton Mill Rd, Williamsburg, Virginia 23188 · MLS #10633340 · Source: REIN MLS + public record. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed — verify independently. School zones subject to change; confirm with the local school division. All locations are described by neutral geographic fact. Equal Housing Opportunity.

✆