Skip to main content
✓ Source: REIN MLS #10660769 · record updated Nov 14, 2026 · synced every 2 min · your inquiry is never resold
Exterior · 1 / 47
4beds
2.1baths
2,028sqft
$197per sqft
8days on market

216 Cary St, Smithfield, VA 23430

ActiveResidential · built 1904 · 0.2 acres · ALL OTHERS AREA 64 · MLS #10660769

OverviewAbout this home

Welcome home to Downtown Smithfield! The property welcomes you with a wide front porch that beckons you back to an earlier time. High ceilings and plenty of large windows continue the feel through the first floor living area. Primary ensuite is on the first floor, with a large open kitchen and dining area, and an additional bedroom. Upstairs there are 2 good size bedrooms, and an oversized full bathroom. There is also a loft area upstairs, perfect for a small office, or reading/play area. Tons of opportunity to customize the space as you like! Excellent proximity to library, YMCA, downtown main street and all the events that Smithfield has to offer. Call to check it out today!

Listing courtesy of Anna Boyer · Howard Hanna Real Estate Svcs. · REIN MLS #10660769

Facts & features

TypeResidential
Year built1904
Price / sqft$197
HOANone
Taxes$2,072/yr
CountyIsle of Wight County VA
MLS #10660769

Interior

Bedrooms
4
Full baths
2
Half baths
1
Approx. sqft
2,028
Stories
2
Flooring
Ceramic, Laminate/LVP
Ensuite bedrooms
1
First-floor bed & full bath
Yes
Total rooms
6
Other rooms
1st Floor BR, 1st Floor Primary BR, Attic, Breakfast Area, PBR with Bath, Porch, Utility Room
Appliances
Dishwasher, Dryer Hookup, Gas Range, Refrigerator, Washer Hookup

Construction & exterior

Style
Farmhouse, Traditional
Subtype
Detached
Foundation
Crawl
Roof
Asphalt Shingle
Exterior
Vinyl
Pool
No Pool

Utilities & systems

Heating
Forced Hot Air
Cooling
Geo Thermal
Water heater
Gas
Water
City/County
Sewer
City/County

Lot, parking & ownership

Lot size
0.2000
Subdivision
ALL OTHERS AREA 64
Zoning
TOWN
Ownership
Fee Simple
Garage
No
Parking
Driveway Spc, Street
Possession
SETTLEMENT
Disclosures
Disclosure Statement, Historical District

Sources: REIN MLS record · city assessor

Tom & Dariya's overview

Our read on this home

by Tom & Dariya Milan, REALTORS® · Brokered by LPT Realty

At a glance

216 Cary Street is a four-bedroom, 1904 Victorian in the heart of Smithfield, Virginia. It sits on a walkable block steps from the historic district, local restaurants, and the Luter Family YMCA. Fort Eustis is about 24 minutes away. This is old-town living with real square footage.

Read the full overview ↓

Why this home stands out

A home built in 1904 carries something newer construction simply cannot offer: genuine architectural character earned over a century. At 2,028 square feet, 216 Cary Street gives you four bedrooms and a layout that reflects an era when rooms had purpose and proportion. The block is quiet, the sidewalks are intact, and the Smithfield Historic District is a short walk away. That combination — historic fabric, walkable streets, and usable space — is rare in Isle of Wight County.

ALL OTHERS AREA 64 and the Smithfield real estate market

Cary Street sits inside Smithfield's oldest residential core, just off Main Street. The blocks here are lined with mature trees and early-twentieth-century homes, many of them well-kept originals. It is the kind of street where neighbors wave and front porches still get used. The Smithfield Historic District is about three blocks away, anchoring the neighborhood's identity and drawing visitors year-round. Riverview Park is nearby too, with views out over the Pagan River. Smithfield itself is a small town with a distinct personality — it is the county seat of Isle of Wight County, and it punches above its weight for dining, local retail, and community events. Getting around is straightforward: Route 10 connects you east toward Suffolk and west toward Windsor. Newport News and the Hampton Roads metro are roughly 30 to 40 minutes depending on your destination. Anyone comparing Smithfield homes for sale will notice that the walkable, historic blocks closest to Main Street are a small and competitive slice of the local market.

What's nearby

Daily errands are easy from 216 Cary Street. Chili Hill Food Market is 0.3 miles away, and Hamtown Mercantile is just a few steps farther at 0.4 miles. Smithfield Gourmet Cafe and Bakery and Taste of Smithfield Restaurant are both within a half-mile walk for breakfast or lunch. The Nelms House LLC and Cure Coffeehouse give you solid coffee options nearby. The Luter Family YMCA is 0.2 miles away — close enough to walk. Riverview Park and the Isle of Wight County Veterans Memorial round out the immediate neighborhood for outdoor time.

For different buyers

Base commute and VA loan notes

Fort Eustis is about 24 minutes from 216 Cary Street, and Langley AFB is roughly 34 minutes. VA loan financing is common in Isle of Wight County, and this property's age and condition make it worth a careful VA appraisal conversation. The historic district location means the neighborhood holds its value well across assignment cycles.

For buyers drawn to character

Four bedrooms, more than 2,000 square feet, and a build year of 1904 — that is a combination worth seeking out. The home sits on one of Smithfield's most intact historic blocks. If you are comparing homes for sale zoned for Smithfield High School and homes for sale zoned for Hardy Elementary School, this address puts you inside both zones while keeping you steps from the town's best restaurants and coffee shops.

More buyer questions

How far is 216 Cary Street from Fort Eustis?

Fort Eustis (Joint Base Langley-Eustis) is about 24 minutes from 216 Cary Street by car. Langley AFB is roughly 34 minutes.

Is 216 Cary Street in the Smithfield Historic District?

The home is not inside the designated historic district boundary, but it is within easy walking distance — about three blocks. The district's character and foot traffic are a direct part of daily life on Cary Street.

What is the flood zone status for 216 Cary Street?

Flood zone information for this address is shown in the FloodRisk tile on this page. Isle of Wight County properties near the Pagan River vary, so reviewing that tile is worthwhile.

How walkable is the Cary Street neighborhood in Smithfield?

Very walkable by small-town standards. Groceries, restaurants, coffee, the YMCA, and Riverview Park are all within half a mile.

Does 216 Cary Street have an HOA?

There is no HOA associated with this address. The property is in an established in-town neighborhood without a homeowners association.

Want to walk Cary Street and see the neighborhood for yourself? Tom and Dariya Milan can arrange a tour and answer your questions about this address.

Summary generated by AI from public records and publicly available information.

Schools · VaHome School ScoreAssigned schools

Our own 1–10 rating, scored from Virginia Department of Education data.

HighSmithfield High School
6/10
Up 0.9 from 2024–25
MiddleSmithfield Middle School
7.3/10
Up 1.2 from 2024–25
ElementaryHardy Elementary School
5.7/10
Up 0.5 from 2024–25

VaHome School Score — calculated by VaHome.com from Virginia Department of Education assessment, progress, and attendance data. Attendance zones come from the MLS listing record; confirm the current zone with the school division before making an offer.

How Far Is?

Driving distance by road and typical drive time via Google Maps, to the nearest location of each.

Also nearby

Distances are straight-line (as the crow flies) from this property, not driving miles. Places within ~1 mile, nearest first. Powered by Google Places.

Homes like this one sell fast — see the next one first

Smithfield$335K – $460K4+ beds

By subscribing you agree to receive listing emails from Tom & Dariya Milan, Realtors, at most one a day. Unsubscribe anytime · Privacy PolicyBrokered by LPT Realty

Military Commute

Drive times to nearest bases

JBLE Ft Eustis

Army

47min·32.5mi

NSA HR

Navy

53min·32mi

JBLE Langley

Air Force

44min·25.5mi

J7 Suffolk

Joint

33min·19.9mi

NWS Yorktown

Navy

50min·34.5mi

Typical drive times from Google Maps, without live traffic. Rush hour and tunnel backups can add time.

Flood & environmentFlood risk (FEMA)

FEMA flood zone X · outside the high-risk area · FIRM 51093C

Flood Risk (FEMA)

Source: FEMA National Flood Hazard Layer · FIRM 51093C

Low / Moderate Risk

FEMA flood zone

X (low to moderate risk)

Base flood elevation

Not applicable in low-risk zones

Zone X is outside the Special Flood Hazard Area; FEMA doesn’t define a BFE here.

Property elevation

34.3 ft above sea level

USGS 3DEP digital elevation model

Outside the high-risk Special Flood Hazard Area. Federal flood insurance is NOT required, though optional preferred-rate NFIP coverage is still worth considering in coastal Hampton Roads.

Data sources: Flood zone and base flood elevation come from FEMA’s National Flood Hazard Layer. Property elevation is sampled from a single point on the parcel using the USGS National Map elevation service — actual elevations across a single property can vary by several feet higher or lower than the figure shown. Use these numbers as a starting reference and do your own due diligence (a professional survey or elevation certificate) before relying on them for any financial, insurance, or construction decision.

Hurricane Evacuation Zone

Not in a designated hurricane evacuation zone.

Source: Virginia Dept. of Emergency Management — Know Your Zone

NeighborhoodSmithfield

homes for sale in Smithfield →

CostPayment calculator

Estimates only. Taxes come from the public record; confirm rates with your lender. VA-eligible buyers: $0-down financing may apply.

Estimate your monthly payment

$2,364/mo

Principal & interest

$2,075

Property tax

$173

Home insurance

$117

PMI

None

HOA/Condo (paid separately)

None

Estimate only. Association (HOA/condo) fees are paid separately and are not included in the payment above. Insurance assumed at 0.35% of home value annually. Actual taxes, insurance, and rate will vary by lender, credit, and property. Contact a lender for a personalized quote.

Value & historyComparables

Asking vs. assessment153% of $262,000City assessment record · taxes $2,072/yr
Land share of assessed value29% · $75,000Improvements $187,000 · assessor record ✓
Price context: similar nearby homes$385,000 – $512,150The 6 most similar homes nearby (same city, within ~20% of this size, ~2.5 mi; 6 sold). Context for judging the asking price, not an appraisal or an estimate of this home's value.
337 Grace ST · 0.1 mi · 1,800 sqft$512,150 sold 2026-05
328 Main ST · 0.2 mi · 1,816 sqft$412,800 sold 2026-08
311 Main ST · 0.2 mi · 2,229 sqft$385,000 sold 2026-07

Own a home nearby? See what it is worth today: What's your Smithfield home worth?

Sale & Tax History

List Price

$399,900

Price / Sq Ft

$197

Annual Taxes

$2,072

Monthly Tax

$173

HOA

None

Tax Rate (effective)

0.52%

Sale Timeline (this listing)

EventDatePriceDetail
ListedNov 6, 2026$399,900—
Currently listed—$399,900—

Public-Records Assessment

Source: City Assessor via Hampton Roads Regional Parcels.

53% above assessment

Total Assessed

$262,000

Land

$75,000

Improvement

$187,000

Looking for multi-year tax assessments or prior sales? REIN MLS only ships data for the current listing. For full property history, check the city assessor record:

Smithfield Assessor (Google)

Tax data above from REIN public-records sync. Sale timeline tracked from this listing's first appearance in our feed forward; prior owner sales are not included.

Comparable Properties

Comps are selected by city, bed count, square footage and price proximity. Composite similarity score weights bed match, sqft variance, price variance, and straight-line distance.

8 days on market: read it in context

Days on market reflects pricing, season, and inventory. Compare it against similar nearby homes before reading anything into it.

CompareThis home next to what else is for sale nearby

HomePriceBedsBathsSqft$ / sqft
216 Cary Stthis home$399,90042.12,028$197
Loading nearby homes for sale…

Active comparables from the REIN MLS, the same homes shown under Comparable Properties. Context for judging the asking price, not an appraisal.

Questions buyers ask

Is 216 Cary St in a good school zone?
The assigned zones on the listing record are Hardy Elementary (VaHome School Score 5.7/10), Smithfield Middle (VaHome School Score 7.3/10), Smithfield (VaHome School Score 6/10). School attendance zones can change — always confirm enrollment with the local school division.
Is 216 Cary St in a flood zone?
FEMA maps this parcel in Zone X, outside the high-risk Special Flood Hazard Area. See the flood section on this page for details and sources.
Does 216 Cary St have an HOA?
No — there are no HOA, condo, or association dues on the listing record for this property.
When was 216 Cary St built?
It was built in 1904, per the listing record.

Answers generated from the listing record, verified school zones, FEMA data, and cached nearby-places data. Never invented.

Tom and Dariya Milan

Tom & Dariya Milan | LPT Realty

See it in person with Tom & Dariya

We're local Hampton Roads Realtors. Pick a day and time; one of us confirms by text and meets you there. Prefer to talk first? Call or text (757) 777-7577.

Free, no obligation. One of us confirms by text, usually within the hour during the day. Your inquiry goes to Tom & Dariya, never resold. We use your details to arrange this tour and to follow up with you about it.

✆