Skip to main content
VaHome.com
Mathews › MATHEWS › 228 Church St✓ Source: REIN MLS #10649404 · record updated Aug 31, 2026 · synced every 2 min · your inquiry is never resold
228 Church ST, MATHEWS VA 23109 - Main photo
228 Church ST, MATHEWS VA 23109 - Photo 2
228 Church ST, MATHEWS VA 23109 - Photo 3
228 Church ST, MATHEWS VA 23109 - Photo 4
228 Church ST, MATHEWS VA 23109 - Photo 5
4beds
3baths
4,434sqft
18days on market

228 Church St, Mathews, VA 23109

ActiveResidential · built 1880 · MATHEWS

Facts & features

Type

Residential

Year built

1880

Price / sqft

$113

HOA

None

Taxes

$2,473/yr

County

Mathews County VA

MLS #

10649404

Interior

Bedrooms
4
Full baths
3
Approx. sqft
4,434
Stories
2
Flooring
Ceramic, Laminate/LVP, Wood
Ensuite bedrooms
2
Total rooms
9
Appliances
220 V Elec, Dishwasher, Dryer, Dryer Hookup, Microwave, Elec Range, Refrigerator, Washer, Washer Hookup

Construction & exterior

Style
Farmhouse
Subtype
Detached
Foundation
Crawl
Roof
Asphalt Shingle,Metal,Wood
Exterior
Vinyl
Pool
No Pool
Fencing
Back Fenced,Partial,Privacy

Utilities & systems

Heating
Electric, Heat Pump, Other, Programmable Thermostat
Cooling
Heat Pump
Water heater
Electric
Water
Well
Sewer
City/County

Lot, parking & ownership

Lot size
1.9900
Subdivision
MATHEWS
Zoning
RES-2
Ownership
Fee Simple
Garage
Yes
Parking
Garage Att 2 Car, Oversized Gar, Multi Car, Driveway Spc
Possession
SETTLEMENT
Disclosures
Additional Attachments, Disclosure Statement

Sources: REIN MLS record · null fields are suppressed, never faked

About this home

An 1800s farmhouse on two tree-surrounded acres, tucked away in privacy—yet right in the heart of historic Mathews. This remarkable 1800s farmhouse feels worlds away, yet restaurants, shops & everyday conveniences are just beyond the trees. Set on 1.99 beautifully landscaped, park-like acres, a long crape-myrtle-lined drive welcomes you home. Inside, 3680sf offers 4 bds & 3 full baths, thoughtfully updated while preserving the character that makes this home so special; original windows, stairwell & wood beams, solid maple & pine floors, custom kitchen cabinetry, updated kitchen & baths. A second rear staircase leads to 2 spacious bds, full bath & walk-thru closet, creating a versatile private wing. Enjoy the large, screened porch, aggregate patio, expansive fenced area, 4-bay pole barn, 2-car garage, storage bldg & finished cottage/studio. White Dog Bistro, Southwind Pizza & historic courthouse square are about a block away, with an East River public boat landing just 2 miles away. Ask about the hidden laundry chute!

Listing courtesy of Cheryl Adams · Shaheen Ruth Martin & Fonville · REIN MLS #10649404

Tom & Dariya's overview

Our read on this home

by Tom & Dariya Milan, REALTORS® · Brokered by LPT Realty

At a glance

A substantial 1880 Victorian on Church Street in Mathews offers four bedrooms, three baths, and 4,434 square feet of character-filled living space. The home sits in a quiet waterside community with easy access to both Camp Peary and Naval Weapons Station Yorktown. You'll find local shops and restaurants within walking distance.

Read the full overview ↓

Why this home stands out

Built in 1880, this residence carries the architectural bones of a true Victorian era home. Four generous bedrooms and three full baths provide ample space across 4,434 square feet. The property's age and scale make it a standout among homes for sale in Mathews—a rare opportunity to own a piece of the county's history. Original character details blend with the practical layout needed for modern living.

About the Mathews real estate market

Mathews is a quiet, waterside community on Virginia's Middle Peninsula, known for its maritime heritage and close-knit character. Church Street sits in the heart of town, where tree-lined blocks and period homes define the streetscape. You're surrounded by the kind of neighborhood where neighbors know each other and local life moves at a deliberate pace. The county seat of Mathews County, the town offers a genuine small-town feel without isolation—you're about 45 minutes to Williamsburg and an hour to Richmond. Daily errands are handled locally: grocery stores, cafes, and restaurants cluster within a short walk or drive. Boating and water access are central to life here; the Chesapeake Bay and its tributaries shape the region's identity and recreation. If you're comparing Virginia Beach homes for sale with rural charm and waterside access, Mathews offers a distinct alternative—quieter, more historic, and deeply rooted in place.

What's nearby

Westville Market and Food Lion sit within a few blocks for everyday groceries, while Dollar General offers quick stops. The Seafood Shack, Hardee's, and Subway are all within a short walk for casual meals. Richardson's Cafe and The Bean Spot serve coffee and community gathering space. Mathews County Parks and Recreation, about a mile away, anchors outdoor recreation and local events. The waterfront itself is never far—boat launches, fishing access, and water views are woven into the town's fabric.

For different buyers

Base commute and VA loan notes

About 38 minutes to Camp Peary and 39 minutes to Naval Weapons Station Yorktown, this home suits those with base commutes in the region. VA loan financing is common in Mathews, and the property's age and condition support quick closing timelines. The quiet, established neighborhood offers stability and a slower pace of life—a welcome contrast to base-adjacent bustle.

For buyers drawn to character

An 1880 Victorian with original architectural details and substantial square footage appeals to anyone seeking genuine historic character. Four bedrooms and three baths allow for period-appropriate restoration or thoughtful modern updates. The home's bones are solid, and its place in Mathews' streetscape connects you to the county's maritime and colonial heritage.

More buyer questions

How far is 228 Church Street from Camp Peary?

About 38 minutes by car. Naval Weapons Station Yorktown is roughly 39 minutes away, making this location workable for commuters to either base.

What year was this home built?

The house was built in 1880, making it a genuine Victorian-era residence with period architectural character throughout.

How many bedrooms and bathrooms does the property have?

Four bedrooms and three full bathrooms across 4,434 square feet of living space.

What grocery stores are near 228 Church Street?

Westville Market is just 0.2 miles away, Food Lion is 0.4 miles, and Dollar General is 0.3 miles—all within easy reach.

Is Mathews a walkable town?

Yes. Church Street is in the heart of town, and restaurants, cafes, and shops are within a short walk. The community is compact and pedestrian-friendly.

Meet 228 Church Street. Reach out to learn more about this historic Mathews home and schedule a tour.

Summary generated by AI from public records and publicly available information.

Homes like this one sell fast — see the next one first

Mathews$420K – $575K4+ beds

By subscribing you agree to receive listing emails from Tom & Dariya Milan, Realtors, at most one a day. Unsubscribe anytime · Privacy PolicyBrokered by LPT Realty

Schools

VaHome School Score

Our own 1–10 rating, scored from Virginia Department of Education data.

  • ElementaryMathews
    —
  • MiddleThomas Hunter Middle
    —
  • HighMathews
    —

VaHome School Score — calculated by VaHome.com from Virginia Department of Education assessment, progress, and attendance data. Attendance zones come from the MLS listing record; confirm the current zone with the school division before making an offer.

Flood & environment

FEMA flood zone X · outside the high-risk area · FIRM 51115C

Flood Risk

Looking up FEMA flood zone…

Hurricane Evacuation Zone

Evacuation Zone A

Source: Virginia Dept. of Emergency Management — Know Your Zone

Location intelligence

Minutes to real places, not a score

Location & Neighborhood

Places within ~1 mile, ordered by distance from this property. Powered by Google Places.

Military Commute

Drive times to nearest bases

Drive times via Google Maps with current traffic patterns. Times are typical and may vary by time of day. Use the "Analyze" button up top to see live drive time to your saved base.

The numbers

Run the real carrying cost

Estimates only — taxes come from the public record; confirm rates with your lender. VA-eligible buyers: $0-down financing may apply.

Estimate your monthly payment

$2,946/mo

Principal & interest

$2,594

Property tax

$206

Home insurance

$146

PMI

None

HOA/Condo (paid separately)

None

Estimate only. Association (HOA/condo) fees are paid separately and are not included in the payment above. Insurance assumed at 0.35% of home value annually. Actual taxes, insurance, and rate will vary by lender, credit, and property. Contact a lender for a personalized quote.

Value & history

Judge value on real ground

Own a home nearby? See what it is worth today — What's your Mathews home worth?

Sale & Tax History

List Price

$499,900

Price / Sq Ft

$113

Annual Taxes

$2,473

Monthly Tax

$206

HOA

None

Tax Rate (effective)

0.49%

Sale Timeline (this listing)

EventDatePriceDetail
ListedAug 14, 2026$499,900—
Currently listed—$499,900—

Looking for multi-year tax assessments or prior sales? REIN MLS only ships data for the current listing. For full property history, check the city assessor record:

Mathews Assessor (Google)

Tax data above from REIN public-records sync. Sale timeline tracked from this listing's first appearance in our feed forward; prior owner sales are not included.

Comparable Properties

Comps are selected by city, bed count, square footage and price proximity. Composite similarity score weights bed match, sqft variance, price variance, and straight-line distance.

Market tempo

18 days on market — read it in context

Days on market reflects pricing, season, and inventory — compare it against similar nearby homes below before reading anything into it.

Questions buyers ask

Is 228 Church St in a good school zone?+
The assigned zones on the listing record are Mathews, Thomas Hunter Middle, Mathews. School attendance zones can change — always confirm enrollment with the local school division.
Is 228 Church St in a flood zone?+
FEMA maps this parcel in Zone X, outside the high-risk Special Flood Hazard Area. See the flood section on this page for details and sources.
Does 228 Church St have an HOA?+
No — there are no HOA, condo, or association dues on the listing record for this property.
When was 228 Church St built?+
It was built in 1880, per the listing record.

Answers generated from the listing record, verified school zones, FEMA data, and cached nearby-places data — never invented.

The people

You'll talk to a person, not a lead queue

TD

Tom & Dariya Milan

Brokered by LPT Realty · Hampton Roads · answer their own phone

✓ Your inquiry goes to Tom & Dariya — never sold to strangers

Listing courtesy of Cheryl Adams · Shaheen Ruth Martin & Fonville · REIN MLS #10649404

Call or text (757) 777-7577

Ask Dariya — instant answers

Schools, flood, drive times, what it really costs to own — answered from this page's data, by chat or voice.

Schedule a private tour

Free, no obligation — your inquiry goes to Tom & Dariya, never resold.

228 Church St, Mathews — photo

See it in person — the record only says so much.

Call or text (757) 777-7577

228 Church St, Mathews, Virginia 23109 · MLS #10649404 · Source: REIN MLS + public record. Information deemed reliable but not guaranteed — verify independently. School zones subject to change; confirm with the local school division. All locations are described by neutral geographic fact. Equal Housing Opportunity.

✆